[Freemanlist2] Aluf Benn - Netanyahu Surging toward a comeback

Freeman Center For Strategic Studies bernards at sbcglobal.net
Fri Mar 9 09:48:20 CST 2007

P.O. Box 35661 * Houston, Texas 77235-5661
Phone or Fax: 713-723-6016 * E-mail: bernards at sbcglobal.net
OUR WEB SITE (URL): http://www.freeman.org
THE MACCABEAN ONLINE: URL:http://www.freeman.org/online.htm
Freeman Center Blog http://www.freeman.org/serendipity/
To Make a tax deductible contribution to the Freeman Center's important educational work, mail check to address above or go to our website to pay by credit card of just click on URL below.
Ignorance Is Weakness - Know The Truth
Self-Inflicted Ignorance Is Suicide
The Freeman Center Is A Defense Against Ignorance 
The USA is not the cause of Israel's problems. The Left and the Arabs are just doing what they do naturally, trying to destroy Israel. It is the responsibility of the Zionist/Nationalist/Religeous Israelis to work for Israel's survival. A good first step would be to throw out the traitors in the Olmert government.

Surging toward a comeback

By Aluf Benn Haaretz 9 March 2007

On Wednesday, a few hours before flying to Washington, Benjamin Netanyahu 
remembered his job as head of the opposition and rattled off some comments 
about Prime Minister Ehud Olmert. "We have to hold elections," Netanyahu 
declared. "The prime minister has lost the public trust."

This was a rare public criticism from the Likud leader, who has been trying 
to appear statesmanlike over the past few months and generally avoids 
frontal assaults on the government. He apparently figured it wasn't worth 
kicking a dead political horse that enjoys negligible support in the polls, 
and that it's better to keep quiet until the government collapses on its 

But something has changed over the last few days.

"I'm convinced that the government will not live out its days," Netanyahu 
said in an interview with Haaretz, in which he accused Olmert of being 
helpless in the face of the Iranian threat. "The nation is searching for 
leadership, and if the government doesn't gain its composure, the change 
will come," he added. "Time will tell whether it happens in a parliamentary 
or electoral process, but I am convinced that it is not just the will of the 
opposition, but the will of the nation."

Although it is possible for the government to recover, there's "no sign" of 
that happening, Netanyahu said. "On the contrary: There is a reverse process 
of maneuvers, delays, futile exercises and dealing with unimportant and 
political exercises, rather than with changes that must be initiated in the 

Netanyahu also identified his political target this week: Kadima's stockpile 
of MKs and voters. The crowning of the Likud leader as Olmert's successor 
during the current Knesset will require that at least 11 members of the 
prime minister's faction return to the Likud. And if the elections are held 
early - something that Netanyahu doubts will happen - the Likud will need 
votes that it lost to Kadima and to Yisrael Beiteinu in 2006.

Perhaps because of this, and perhaps due to the upcoming Winograd Commission 
report on the war in Lebanon and its potential ramifications, Netanyahu is 
signaling a move to the center, and is making surprisingly optimistic 
statements about the chances of a political process with the Palestinians.

"I see a unique opportunity for progress in the peace process with moderate 
Arab partners, for a simple reason: There is identification of a shared 
threat," he explained. "Even if Iran's nuclear program is stopped, the 
extremist Islamic threat exists, and that allows for the creation of 
alliances with various elements in the Arab world as well as in Palestinian 

And would you agree to withdraw from territories as part of such a peace 

"If I knew that I had a genuine partner. I have already proved that I am 
prepared to make certain concessions, not sweeping or unlimited, but I 
demanded mutuality and as long as I received it, I was able to progress."

Would you accept the Saudi initiative (withdrawal from all territory in 
exchange for fully normalized ties between Israel and the Arab world, and a 
"just and agreed-upon" solution to the refugee problem) as the basis for 

"The Saudi initiative cannot be implemented in terms of its details, but we 
have to aspire to an arrangement in which it is clear that if Israel is 
required to make additional concessions, it knows from the start that there 
will be no more demands and that the conflict is reaching an end. That did 
not exist in the negotiations that we conducted until now. We have to make 
an arrangement, get to the end, and then go backward."

Head of the Majlis

Despite the optimistic statements, Netanyahu does not currently see a 
Palestinian partner for an agreement, and demands that the peace partner 
will recognize Israel's right to exist. He is also not enthusiastic about 
the renewal of the Syrian negotiations channel, and says he tends to accept 
the assessment of Mossad espionage agency head Meir Dagan, that Syria is not 
heading toward peace. Netanyahu quotes intelligence assessments that the 
Syrian military-acquisitions budget has increased tenfold. On this matter, 
his position is no different from Olmert's.

Netanyahu has long been acting like the opposition head of the Majlis, 
Iran's parliament, rather than that of the Knesset. His public criticism is 
directed toward Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. Netanyahu goes around 
the world and calls for Ahmadinejad to stand trial for incitement to 
genocide. His upcoming trip to the United States will also center around the 
struggle against Iran and its nuclear program. He will speak at the American 
Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) lobby's annual conference next week, 
and meet with U.S. Vice President Dick Cheney and the leading candidates for 

"The Iranian regime is more vulnerable than it seems," said Netanyahu. "It's 
possible to act against it in a firm and focused way, to destabilize it, or 
stop the nuclear program, or both. Its major weakness is in the economic 

The idea of imposing a "secondary boycott" on the Iranian economy is at the 
center of Netanyahu's campaign. It involves convincing the managers of 
pension funds for civil servants in every state in the United States, which 
hold assets worth hundreds of billions of dollars, to pull their investments 
from some 400 companies, from European and other countries, conducting 
business with Iran. Such a boycott would threaten the Iranian economy and 
the stability of its government. Netanyahu also wants to send AIPAC 
activists to governors and state legislatures in a bid to get them to order 
the pension funds to impose the boycott. This week, he submitted a similar 
bill in the Knesset, which, if passed, would ban Israeli investment in 
multinational companies active in Iran.

"All who feared military efforts against Iran should welcome an economic 
means that can render military activity unnecessary," Netanyahu said.

In his latest travels in Europe, he presented this idea to members of the 
French National Assembly's foreign affairs committee and to members of the 
British parliament. He tells doves to support the boycott so as to prevent 
an attack on Iran; the hawks will support pressure on the Iranians anyway. 
"It's not certain that the effort will succeed," Netanyahu admitted. "But 
even if it doesn't, at least public opinion will be prepared for tougher 

Same 1938 analogy

In a speech before the General Assembly of the United Jewish Communities in 
Los Angeles in November, Netanyahu made a chilling analogy between 
present-day Iran and 1938 Germany. Since then, he has continued to draw this 
analogy. In his talks in Washington next week, he will suggest the 
establishment of a "coalition against genocide" that would act against the 
genocide in Darfur - an issue that is important to the Democrats - and 
against Ahmadinejad, the Holocaust denier who has called for Israel's 
destruction. The coalition would be "against a genocide that is carried out, 
that which is denied, and that which is planned," Netanyahu explained.

Is Israel facing a holocaust?

"I think it's possible to stop this holocaust, these threats. The situation 
is identical to 1938, in that an extreme ideology is present that is arming 
itself with weapons, with the declared attempt of destroying a significant 
portion of the Jewish people. The situation is different, in that there is a 
State of Israel that can and must elicit international pressure, and also 
because there is [now] a historic perspective. When [U.S. Secretary of 
State] Condoleezza Rice said that we are not in 1938, she was not referring 
to a change in the intention to destroy, but to the application of the 
historic lesson. On the contrary: Let us see the application, but it depends 
on actions carried out in the exhaustible time [that's left]."

Netanyahu quoted the Mossad chief's assessment that Iran will achieve 
nuclear capability within about three years. "That's not a lot of time, 
1,000 days," the Likud leader said.

Aren't you concerned that your talk of a holocaust will lead to 
demoralization and will encourage young Israelis to flee just in order to be 

"The right thing that generates hope is not repressing the threat, or 
blurring it and concealing it, but the readiness to face it and to muster 
the many forces we have, and to lead the world to understand and stand up 
against it. There is a future, there is the capacity to halt this, to stop 
Iran and, if necessary, to build a massive deterrence."

Is the Olmert government doing enough?

"Unfortunately not. I would like to see a greater effort, and I said so to 
the prime minister. An all-out effort, which tries to use all the available 
tools to generate economic, political and public-relations pressure to 
isolate Iran, destabilize the regime or freeze the nuclear program. A master 
plan is needed, with the direct involvement of the prime minister."

Netanyahu advocates significant investment in development of defense and 
deterrence methods. When he was prime minister, he increased the budget for 
that, and today notes that Israel "will be required over the coming decades 
to build capabilities of a much larger scope than what there is." He said 
the necessary technology exists, and that if Israel continues along the 
right economic path, it will be able to fund the development on its own.

"On these matters," he said, "the person in opposition, and certainly the 
opposition head, faces a genuine dilemma. In the internal realm, things must 
be said and must be subject to discussion, argument and criticism, but they 
cannot be part of the public discourse. There is a paradox concerning 
everything related to nonconventional matters. This discussion takes place, 
and I take an active part in it as the opposition chairman, in 
subcommittees, and I think that to a large extent [I am] also an expediting 
factor on certain matters. But I cannot go into it in public."

'A responsible opposition'

Benjamin Netanyahu loves to quote Winston Churchill, whose warnings 
concerning Hitler's arms buildup in the 1930s were not heeded. So, why 
shouldn't Netanyahu act like Churchill, who became the first lord of the 
admiralty in the government of his rival, Neville Chamberlain? When such an 
existential threat is at hand, why shouldn't Netanyahu boost Olmert and run 
his public campaign around the world as a cabinet member instead of from the 

"My colleagues and I acted as a responsible opposition," said Netanyahu. "We 
supported the government from day one, including during the war and 

Why drag the country into an election campaign when time is running out and 
the Iranian bomb is ticking? After all, Ahmadinejad won't wait.

"A vast majority of the public wants elections precisely for this reason, 
[because] there need to be rapid changes of leadership. Elections can be 
held in a few short weeks and a government can be brought in to take care of 
the problem. How will it help you for time to pass like sand between your 
fingers without any action and without the necessary steps being taken for 
our defense, to recruit the world against Iran? In such situations, it's 
desirable for the public to give a renewed mandate to deal with these 
threats, which didn't happen in the previous elections, which were conducted 
on the basis of completely different assumptions that in the meantime proved 
to be false. In a democracy, a government that is chosen on a platform that 
turns out to no longer be valid needs to go back to the public and ask for a 
renewed mandate. That's why in a parliamentary democracy, there are ways to 
replace a government in mid-term, as a result of deficient functioning or a 
change in mandate."

The Prime Minister's Bureau said in response to Netanyahu's comments that 
the prime minister was directing a "complex operation" to deal with the 
possibility of a nuclear Iran.

"Management of the Iranian problem is being coordinate by the prime 
minister, and involves hundreds and thousands of people in the security 
branches, intelligence and political bodies of the State of Israel," the 
bureau said in a statement. "This is a complex operation, more sensitive 
than any other, to which the prime minister is dedicating long hours of his 
schedule every week.

"Just recently, the prime minister held a meeting with subcommittee members 
of the [Knesset] Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, in which he provided 
them with a summary of Israeli activity on the matter. All the members of 
the committee - apparently excluding Mr. Netanyahu - received a completely 
different impression [from the picture he portrays], and even made the 
effort to point this out repeatedly to the prime minister. There is no 
subject or topic that Mr. Netanyahu does not try to enlist in an effort to 
damage the government, even if it will entail damage to the State of 
Israel's most crucial interests. Thus, he proves once again that there is 
nothing like scare tactics to serve his political goals."
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://list.freeman.org/pipermail/freemanlist2/attachments/20070309/31aa5aac/attachment-0009.html>

More information about the Freemanlist2 mailing list