[Freemanlist2] Dr. Aaron Lerner Commentary: Ma'an News Agency terminology - wake up call

Freeman Center For Strategic Studies bernards at sbcglobal.net
Fri Mar 2 10:12:01 CST 2007

P.O. Box 35661 * Houston, Texas 77235-5661
Phone or Fax: 713-723-6016 * E-mail: bernards at sbcglobal.net
OUR WEB SITE (URL): http://www.freeman.org
THE MACCABEAN ONLINE: URL:http://www.freeman.org/online.htm
Freeman Center Blog http://www.freeman.org/serendipity/
To Make a tax deductible contribution to the Freeman Center's important educational work, mail check to address above or go to our website to pay by credit card of just click on URL below.
Ignorance Is Weakness - Know The Truth
Self-Inflicted Ignorance Is Suicide
The Freeman Center Is A Defense Against Ignorance 
May this Purim bring deliverance from our enemies, both internal (Olmert) and external. Hag Samaech! 

Weekly Commentary: Ma'an News Agency terminology - wake up call
Dr. Aaron Lerner                   Date: 1 March, 2007

"each language has its own terminology and special meanings, and that Ma'an 
will not stop using terms such as "martyr", "resistance" and equivalent 
terms, in Arabic."
Response by Ma'an News Agency to an article by Itamar Marcus and Barbara 
Crook of Palestinian Media Watch.

Ma'an News Agency is as mainstream Palestinian as they come.

The independent news agency, bankrolled by the governments of Netherlands 
and Denmark, has taken on an important role as a provider of information 
about developments on the Palestinian side.

And while its English language website certainly makes no bones about its 
orientation, it tends to avoid the kind of terminology that makes some of 
the official PA website sound downright silly.  Ma'an calls the Israeli Army 
by its official English name - "IDF", for example, while the official PA 
websites, in contrast, use the Palestinian invention "IOF" (Israeli 
Occupation Force):

So it came as a surprise to those only following the English Ma'an website 
when Itamar Marcus and Barbara Crook of Palestinian Media Watch prepared a 
comparison of the English and Arabic Ma'an Websites.

They found that besides terming the murder of Israeli civilians by a suicide 
bomber an act of "martyrdom" and "resistance", the Arabic language website 
identified Eilat as being "located in the south of occupied Palestine" and 
termed Jaffa an "occupied city" -  meaning that literally everywhere in 
Israel is "occupied".

Ma'an's reaction to the criticism is instructive.

They didn't back down.

Instead they essentially argued that, when writing in Arabic, it was proper 
to use terminology that rejects the validity of Israel's existence in any 
border and praises the murder of Israeli civilians as part of the ongoing 
Arab war against the Jewish State.

As Ma'an English news editor, Rashid Shahin, put it, dropping this 
terminology in their Arabic website would mean reflecting "the Israeli point 
of view."

The people at Ma'an News Agency aren't radicals.  They are the kind of 
"moderates" that U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice has in mind when 
she talks about a Palestinian state.  They are the peace loving Palestinians 
she compares to Reverend Martin Luther King engaged in a peaceful struggle 
for equality as if Gaza and Nablus are no different than Selma Alabama.

But when Martin Luther King addressed his fellow Blacks, he didn't switch to 
terminology that embraced and glorified murder while rejecting the rights of 
those who are not Black.

[Rice's continuous fixation on this false equivalence dangerously distorts 
the reality of the situation - the Blacks of America did not try to destroy 
the U.S. in 1776, nor were Blacks part of a great pan-Black nation 
stretching from Canada down to Argentina that considered the U.S. to be a 
temporary foreign entity to be ultimately ejected from the America's 

There is an important message for policy makers from Ma'an's response.

"Peace" and "reconciliation" aren't a photo op signing ceremony on the White 
Lawn away.

It is going to require considerably more patience than that.

The challenge today for Israel today is not to come up with right wording 
for an ersatz peace treaty but instead insure that the Jewish State 
continues to thrive despite the reality of the neighborhood.

Dr. Aaron Lerner, Director IMRA (Independent Media Review & Analysis)
(Mail POB 982 Kfar Sava)
Tel 972-9-7604719/Fax 972-3-7255730
INTERNET ADDRESS: imra at netvision.net.il
Website: http://www.imra.org.il
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://list.freeman.org/pipermail/freemanlist2/attachments/20070302/a6e380a3/attachment-0009.html>

More information about the Freemanlist2 mailing list